When Shame Scorns, Silences, and Separates
I can’t believe my life has come to this. A public spectacle. I’ve seen the looks on their faces—the disdain. I’ve heard the whispers as I walk past. I’ve caught them staring at me, only to divert their eyes when my gaze meets theirs. I’ve never even mattered to them before now, before him. But now I’m the pawn they’re using to trap this rabbi named Jesus.
How did I end up here? I knew it was wrong, but it satisfied the ache in my soul, even if just for a moment. The way he looked at me, the way he said my name, the way he laughed and enjoyed me—I’ve craved that kind of delight all my life. I just wanted to be known, to be seen, to feel loved and accepted.
My husband is a good and faithful man—a hard worker, laboring day and night to provide for us. How could I do this to him? I’ve brought such shame to his name, to my family. I am such a failure, a disgrace; I always have been.
It’s all too much—the crowd, the noise, the accusations, my sin. Not one of them even calls me by name; I’m just “this woman caught in adultery.” Known only by my sin and shame. They encircle me, no escape from their knowing eyes. I am naked before them.
“Teacher,” they call him. They don’t even recognize him or honor him as Lord. I’m not sure who they detest more—me or him? And yet, we both stand here on trial. I know why I am here. But what about him? What could they possibly have against this man of God—except that he associates with people like me?
They say to him, “The law of Moses says to stone her. What do you say?” There it is; the trap is set. My fate—my very life—is in his hands. My chest tightens. My heart and mind race. What will he say? But he just stands there, silent. Each moment that passes is agonizing, but then he begins to move, glancing at me as he stoops down, bending his knee to the dirt. Is he about to cast the first stone?
But he doesn’t look at me the way they do. There’s something different in his gaze—painful, but in a different way.
I dare to look at the crowd. All eyes are on him. They’re just as confused as I am. What is he writing in the dust? Everyone moves forward to see what he’s doing. The stench of blood and smoke from their sacrifices fills my nose. They press him for an answer, but he seems so unbothered by their badgering. How is he so calm? Surely he knows they’re just using me to get to him.
Finally, he stands. My heart starts to race again. What is he going to do now? He gazes around the circle, looking each one in their eyes. “Let the one who has never sinned throw the first stone,” he says, and then he bends back down with finger once again to the dirt. Again, he looks at me. I can’t bear it, so I stare at the dusty sandaled feet of my accusers instead.
I can’t believe my eyes. They’re walking away. One by one, the crowd thins until they’re all gone. Everyone. Except for me and him.
“Where are your accusers? Didn’t even one of them condemn you?”
I bring my eyes to meet his. “No, Lord.”
His eyes. Fixed on me. Almost seeing through me. Intense and yet, tender and compassionate. His gaze makes me ache with such shame, so much regret, and yet, I can’t look away.
He reaches toward me, taking my hand, and lifting me from the dirt. This holy man touches me.
Then he speaks again, “Neither do I. Go and sin no more.”
I can hardly believe it. He knows who I am and what I’ve done. And yet he doesn’t look on me with scorn. Nor does he turn his face away in disgust. He set his gaze on me. In spite of my sin deserving death, he disarmed my accusers.
Could he offer what I’ve always wanted? To be fully known, in my brokenness and sin and pain, and loved fully?
My heart races again, but not with fear or shame. It’s beating as if for the first time. The blood of new life is flowing through my veins.
I wrote this creative narrative retelling of the woman caught in adultery in John 8 for a shame study I co-created while on staff as a Women’s Discipleship Advisor several years ago. I held true to what Scripture does reveal to us, but I added fictional details to capture our imagination and help us find ourselves in the story.
You don’t have to have the same story as this woman to identify with her. I haven’t committed adultery. But I know the deep regret of actions you thought yourself incapable of. I’ve never been publicly humiliated before a crowd of onlookers, at least not to the extent this woman was. But I know humiliation and embarrassment.
What I am most acquainted with is her shame—the kind that condemns and accuses. The shame that fixes your eyes to the ground because you can’t bear the knowing gaze of another. The kind that strips you of your dignity and denies you your place at Jesus’ table.
It’s the specter that haunts us in the faces and voices of others, including our own.
Their eyes convey contempt, rejection, disgust. Worse, they convey an apathy that says you aren’t even worthy of consideration, care, or compassion.
It’s the taunts and mockery. “Who are you?” they say.
They name you. Weak. Failure. Dirty. Worthless. Stupid.
It’s the whispers so faint you sometimes barely notice them, but so acute they pierce your soul.
“You are too much. Too loud. Too strong. Too vocal. Too _____ (fill in the blank).
“You are not enough. Not strong enough. Not smart enough. Not faithful enough. Not _____ enough.”
They remind you of every failure, every weakness. They don’t convict; they condemn, sentencing you to a life of groveling, striving, performing.
They cast you out, isolating you or sending you into hiding. “You don’t belong here,” they say. “If they really knew who you are or what you did or how you are struggling, they would reject you.”
Their goal is to keep you bent low, not in humility, but in humiliation.
They use whatever ammunition is available to them—sins you’ve committed, sins committed against you, or something you’re associated with—as long as they can keep you from seeing his face or hearing his voice.
Adultery? You’re unforgivable. Sex before marriage? You’re ruined. Depressed or anxious? Your faith is weak. Didn’t read your Bible this morning? You’re lazy and don’t love Jesus enough. Divorced? Failure. Never married? Unlovable. Didn’t go to college? Incompetent.
They press in closer. So close you can feel their hot breath on the back of your neck.
I have been shamed by other people. And you’ve probably experienced it too. But those specters—the gazes that haunt and the voices that taunt—mostly lurk in the dark of my own mind. More often than not, the face looking at me with unrelenting disappointment isn’t another’s; it’s my own staring back at me in the mirror. And the voices aren’t those of my neighbors, co-workers, or community group. It’s my own voice that condemns and accuses.
In the series The Chosen, the writers depict a fictionalized narrative in which Mary Magdalene is caught in a spiral of shame.¹ Though Jesus had redeemed her, she feels unworthy of his love and her place among his closest followers. The shame she feels silences and separates her from the others. And when she can no longer hold onto the truth, she retreats into the darkness where the shadows feel truer than the light.
But the disciples find her and bring her back to Jesus. He speaks tenderly to her, but still she can’t bear to look at him. The voices continue to tell her she is too bad, too stained, to receive Jesus’ grace and mercy… again. Shame keeps her eyes pinned to the ground.
But Jesus is unwilling to let her avert his gaze.
“Mary, look up…Look at me.”
And when she does, she sees his face. His eyes, full of compassion, staring back at her. She sees Jesus seeing her—broken and beloved. She hears words of forgiveness and acceptance spoken over her, truth she lost sight of in her shame. It is then that she is freed from the shame spiral that kept her from experiencing his love, and is able to take her place at his table again.
But finding Jesus’ face in the crowd isn’t a one-time moment. It’s something we practice every time shame whispers or glances our way. And that’s not easy when shame engulfs you. Sometimes, we are too mired in shame and, like Mary, we need others to help us get to Jesus. We need to see his love reflected in their compassion and kindness; we need to hear his truths spoken through another. We need to feel his pursuit and invitation extended through another.
We might need visual reminders. I have two that help me when the shadows seem truer than the light. The first is a sign in our main living area that says, “Get to Jesus.” Those three words remind me that Jesus is the cure for my shame. He is the hope I need. The second is a tattoo on my arm that says, “called. loved. kept.” based on the opening greeting to believers in Jude 1:1. When shame says I am unlovable, rejected, and unwanted, Christ speaks a truer word.
When shame presses in on you like the crowd surrounding the woman in John 8, it’s easy to lose sight of Jesus. Or when it keeps your eyes pinned to the ground, like Mary, it’s hard to look up. But he is there. Waiting for you to find his face in the crowd. Waiting for you to look up and see him seeing you. Waiting for you to hear his voice:
“My yoke is easy, and my burden is light, because it is the work I accomplished for you on your behalf. You are carrying something you are not meant to carry, something you are not capable of carrying. Lay it down and receive what I am offering you. I have forgiven you. I have cleansed you. I have accepted you. You don’t have to be enough, because I am.”
When the negative voices whisper in your ear today, condemning and accusing, listen and look for him. Listen for him calling you beloved, clean, forgiven, chosen. Look for his gaze. See his face is turned toward you with compassion and love, not away from you in disappointment and disgust. See his desire is for you—to heal, forgive, and restore your dignity and place at his table.
When shame scorns, silences, and separates, find Jesus’ face in the crowd and listen to his voice.
Engage the Scripture
1. Read John 8:1-11 a few times, maybe in a couple of different translations.
What stands out to you in this passage?
What is Jesus’ posture toward the woman?
Write down everything he says to her.
2. Read Romans 8:1-2, 31-39.
Paul says “there is no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (v.1). How might this apply to the voices that accuse and condemn you?
Verses 33-34 ask who can bring an accusation against God’s chosen ones and remind us that Christ himself intercedes for us. Who or what do you most often let take the role of an accuser? What changes when you picture Christ as your advocate?
Explore Your Story
1. Think about a recent time you felt the sting of shame. What triggered it? How did it impact you?
2. When shame speaks to you, what words does it use? Write down the words or phrases you hear most often. Whose voice does it sound like?
Encounter the Savior
1. Shame attacks our identities, naming us (ex., failure, worthless, unlovable). Write down some of the names that shame has attached to you. Then, using Scripture as your guide, write down some of the names God calls you.
2. What are some practical ways you can practice finding Jesus’ face in the crowd? Choose one you can implement this week.
Experience shalom
Find a quiet spot to sit with a journal. Pray and ask the Spirit to guide you, and let Scripture be your guardrails. If at any time this feels overwhelming, open your eyes and take a few deep breaths. You can stop whenever you need to.
Close your eyes and take a few deep breaths. Imagine yourself as the woman in the story and reflect on the following prompts:
Imagine your thoughts are a crowd of people surrounding you.
What would they be saying to you? What names would they call you?
What would their faces communicate?
What does your body feel as you imagine this? Your mind? Your heart?
How do you feel compelled to respond (ex. retreat, fight, hide)?
Now, find Jesus’ face in that crowd. Listen for his voice.
What does he say? What does he call you?
What does the look on his face communicate?
What does your body feel as you imagine this? Your mind? Your heart?
How do you feel compelled to respond?
Now take a few more deep breaths and sit in his presence for as long as feels possible. This exercise may be hard the first time. That’s ok. It has taken me a long time to be willing to receive Christ's compassion, much less to allow myself to experience it.
The Wholehearted Project is reader-supported.
If you enjoy or have benefited from the content, would you consider supporting future content by becoming a financial supporter through a one-time gift at Buy Me A Coffee or becoming a recurring supporter at Liberapay.